YOUR CHURCH INSURANCE
SPECIALIST
Experience and passion for protecting your ministry
About Us
Anchor Insurance Agencies started in 1999 and for over 26 years have served business and individual insurance needs. In 2019, ChurchInsure was launched as a separate division with the focus on protecting churches and the organizations and nonprofits they support. It’s our honor to serve these organizations and we have been blessed with the opportunities to serve so many churches across the country.
ChurchInsure is…
- An independent agency with access to multiple insurers of religious institutions
- A consultant that can identify gaps in your current program and provide solutions designed to meet the specific needs of your ministry.
- A steward that provides you with options designed to give you the best value for your premium dollar.
- An advisor that provides you with resources and training.
- A partner that cares about your ministry and is committed to helping you protect the people in your organization.
- A Division of Anchor Insurance Agencies
Our Team
As active members of our local churches, each member of our team is committed to providing excellent support to our church clients and helping them make the best decisions as stewards of the church.
Rich Winkler, President
- Phone: 252-275-9500, ext 1217
- Email: rich@insurance.church
Paul Cossentine, Religious and Non-Profit Program Manager
- Phone: 252-275-9500, ext 1255
- Email: paul@insurance.church
Sarah Thomas, Religious and Non-Profit Customer Service
- Phone: 252-275-9500, ext 1257
- Email: sarah@insurance.church
Jennifer Bick, Bilingual CSR
- Phone: 252-275-9500, ext. 1250
- Email: jennifer.bick@anchor-insurance.com
Insurance Carriers
Coverages
The “business” of running a ministry is time-consuming and complex, that’s why we are here to help.
If you have any questions or need to make changes to your policies, always feel free to contact us by phone at:
(336) 250-0075 or email at info@insurance.church
PROPERTY
- BUILDINGS
- BUSINESS PERSONAL
- PROPERTY
- INLAND MARINE – FINE
- ARTS
- WIND STORM
- EARTHQUAKE
LIABILITY
- GENERAL LIABILITY
- ABUSE & MOLESTATION
- COUNSELING
- DIRECTORS & OFFICERS
- EMPLOYMENT
- PRACTICES
- RELIGIOUS FREEDOM
- CYBER RISK
AND MORE…
- WORKERS’
- COMPENSATION
- COMMERCIAL AUTO
- UMBRELLA AND EXCESS
- SPECIAL EVENTS
- STUDENT ACCIDENT
- VOLUNTEER ACCIDENT
MISSION TRIP INSURANCE
ChurchInsure is proud to partner with Mission Trip Insurance, a division of Insurance Consultants International. We offer this program to address the risks of your ministry, members, volunteers, students, and employees when traveling.
MINISTRYSAFE
Learn how to protect children from sexual abuse with an effective safety system. MinistrySafe and ChurchInsure are working together to protect children from sexual abuse.
Resources
Blog
Your HSA: A Beginner’s Guide
New to a Health Savings Account (HSA)? Here’s What You Need to Know As the name suggests, a Health Savings Account(HSA) is a special savings account used to pay for… read more
Risk Insights: Candles and Fire Risk
Candles are used in various religious services and ceremonies and can be an essential part of worship. However, they can pose serious fire risks to religious institutions and should be… read more
New Legislation Updates ACA Reporting Rules
At the close of 2024, Congress passed two new pieces of legislation: the Paperwork Burden Reduction Act and the Employer Reporting Improvement Act. These laws simplify the Affordable Care Act… read more
Risk Insights: Avoiding Slip, Trip and Fall Liabilities in Religious Organizations
Slips, trips and falls are some of the most common injuries across industry lines, with religious organizations being no exception. In fact, the nature of these organizations’ operations—namely, experiencing frequent… read more
Strategies for Buying Church Insurance (and Getting Better Rates!)
When it comes to buying insurance for your church, you want to protect your organization and congregation the best way possible while keeping an eye on your budget. But typically,… read more
In Defense of Religious Liberty
Across the street from the First Christian Church of Fredericksburg, VA, the Thomas Jefferson Religious Freedom Monument stands in tribute to the Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom written by Thomas… read more
Why Partnering with the Right Church Insurance Advisor Matters
Insurance isn’t just a purchase—it’s a relationship. Choosing the right advisor can make the difference between peace of mind and painful gaps in coverage. Here’s why the advisor behind your… read more
Is Your Ministry Fully Protected? 5 Questions Every Church Should Ask About Their Insurance Coverage
At ChurchInsure, we believe protecting your ministry goes beyond just having a policy. It’s about partnering with you to ensure your people, property, and purpose are fully covered. Here are… read more
Articles & eBooks
- ChurchInsure – Avoiding Sexual Abuse Liability
- ChurchInsure – COVID-19 Reopening Considerations for Faith-Based Organizations
- ChurchInsure – Designing a Post-Coronavirus Workplace
- ChurchInsure – Job Interviews: What’s Illegal to Ask
- ChurchInsure – Liabilities for the Board of Directors
- ChurchInsure – Managing Volunteers in Your Organization
- ChurchInsure – Premises Liability Risk for Faith-Based Organizations
- ChurchInsure – Youth Protection Measures for Religious Organizations
- CDC – COVID Considerations for Communities of Faith
- FEMA – Emergency Operation Plans for Houses of Worship
- Glatfelter – Certificate of Insurance as a Risk Management Tool
- Glatfelter – Dealing with the Media
- Glatfelter – Internet and Email Usage
- GuideOne – Child Safety for Nurseries, Daycares, and Playgrounds
- GuideOne – GuideVantage Abuse Prevention Resources
- GuideOne – Installing a New Roof: Tips and Considerations
- GuideOne – Is Armed Security Right for your Church: Q&A
- GuideOne – Kitchen and Food Safety
- GuideOne – Religious Expression and Your Church
- GuideOne – Reopening Religious Organizations
- Southern Mutual Church Insurance – Child Youth Manual
- Southern Mutual Church Insurance – Church Security Manual
Videos & Webinars
VIDEO/WEBINAR: CHURCH SECURITY WEBINAR: 5 Things You Need to Know (1 HOUR) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: 15 Passenger Van Driver Training (16 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: Preventing Slip and Fall Injuries at Church (20 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: Starting a Safety Ministry (16 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: Fire Safety for Churches (30 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: CHILD PROTECTION (20 Minutes) – Source: Southern Mutual Church Insurance
Child Protection – YouTube
VIDEO Playlist: SafeChurch Training Videos Playlist (142 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
Webinar: How to Prevent Financial Fraud at Your Church (60 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
VIDEO: Act to Keep Children’s Ministry Safe (20 Minutes) – Source: GuideOne Insurance
Sample Waivers and Checklists
Templates
Mandatory Reporting Laws by State
What people are saying
“Without ChurchInsure, Florida Global Methodist Churches would be lost. My father was in insurance most of his life, and I can sincerely say I’ve never come across anyone who cares more about their clients and delivers better service. Thank you, ChurchInsure”
Jay Therrell, Superintendent, Florida Annual Conference of the Global Methodist Church
Customer Center
Need a certificate?
To obtain evidence of coverage for a special event or to add a party as a certificate holder, please complete the form below and submit your request. Unless we need additional information, we’ll email the certificate to you within one business day.
If you need the certificate sooner, please call us at (252) 275-9500.
Please Note: We cannot bind, accept, modify, or cancel coverage through this website, via email, or voicemail.
Need to File a Claim?
If this is an emergency, please call 911.
If you have been in an accident or need to file a claim, please choose one of these options:
- You may contact your insurance company directly by phone, by email or website. Specific information, including your policy number, is provided on the Contact List included in your ChurchInsure “Welcome” email.
- Contact your agent at (252) 275-9500.
- Submit your information below, and we will contact you shortly:
Need to make Change to Your Policy?
Please contact us if you have made an important change at your church, such as:
- Acquiring or building new facilities
- Adding or subtracting staff positions
- Adding or subtracting vehicles
- Launching a new ministry, such as a school, camp or food bank
Please Note: We cannot bind, accept, modify, or cancel coverage through this website, via email, or voice mail.
Submit your information below, and we will contact you shortly:
free Consultation
Contact Paul Cossentine, CIC for your free, no-obligation consultation at (252)-275-9500.
OR
Use the form below.